Aerial view of a used car as it drives down a winding curvy road through a forest

When you are searching for the most reliable used cars in Colorado Springs, you need to know where to turn. In this article, we will focus on some affordable yet reliable used cars, the most reliable used car brands, and our pick as to whom is the most reliable used car of all. Whether you need to stick to a budget with your next dependable used car or you want to splurge, we know which vehicles are the most reliable used cars that you can count on for years to come.

View Used Car Inventory

Used Cars with the Best Reliability

After examining the options of the most reliable used cars, several factors should be considered. You want a vehicle that rarely breaks down, offers longevity, has a lower depreciation rate than other models, and very few mechanical issues. In our time working with used cars, we've found that the following 5 models are some of the most reliable used cars you will find in Colorado Springs.

Our top pick for the most reliable used car is the Toyota 4Runner. It's been at the top of the charts for more than a decade. This used Toyota SUV receives high ratings for durability and depreciation. Another Toyota model to consider is a used Toyota Camry. This midsize sedan has been a top seller since the 1990s. From 2002 through 2017, the Camry scored high in reliability ratings from Consumer Reports.

If you want a reliable used car filled with luxury, consider the Lexus ES. It's based on the Toyota Camry, so you know it's well built. Still, there are plenty of features that allow you to travel in style and high-class opulence. Another reliable used car is the Mazda3. This compact car offers some of the highest ratings on the market. The power equipment, braking system, transmission, and engine all perform better than most of the competition. Finally, you'll want to look at the Honda Accord if you want a reliable used car. From 2011 until 2017, the Accord received top reliability scores. This leaves us with no doubt that this used car will impress you as well.

Reliable Used Cars Under $10,000

If you want reliable used cars, but can't afford to spend a lot, there are some great budget-friendly options at our used car dealerships throughout Colorado. One of the most popular options at many used car dealerships in Colorado Springs includes the 2012 Mazda Mazda3. It's available in two body styles and is fun to drive. We also recommend the 2011 Toyota Corolla. Just like a Honda Civic, this car is one of the best compacts around. It's earned its reputation for low-cost operation and quality.

We should feature the 2010 Subaru Outback as well. This versatile, used AWD car offers the ruggedness of an SUV and is ideal for anyone that enjoys the outdoors. Another option for the most reliable used car under $10,000 is the 2013 Kia Soul. This funky vehicle is efficient and offers plenty of utility. Finally, you might consider the 2012 Subaru Legacy. It's another option with standard AWD plus there are plenty of interior upgrades that don't feel low-budget.

View Used Cars Under $10,000

Best Car Brands for Reliability

Close up view of a magnifying glass sitting on a map with a set of Toyota car keys to the right

As you look at the list of reliable used cars and used trucks from Colorado Springs to Denver, you will find three brands that consistently perform well. We regularly see these three brands outperform the rest. Lexus leads the packs in reliable used car sales, especially with their GX and ES models. Toyota cars seem to always hit the top of the charts, especially with the Prius, 4Runner, and Camry. Finally, you will find that the Mazda lineup has a lot to offer in terms of reliability. Not only is the Mazda3 a hot seller throughout used car sales, but so is the MX-5 Miata.

Most Reliable Used Car to Buy

We highly recommend the Toyota Camry or Toyota 4Runner as the most reliable used car available for purchase. Of all the used cars in Colorado Springs, you will find many Camrys and 4Runners often offered at reasonable prices. As you enter your used car buying journey, you'll find older models for a bargain price or newer models if you want the latest upgrades. Visit the best used car dealerships in Colorado right here at the Phil Long Family of Dealerships to find the reliable used vehicles you've been hoping for. We are ready to help you today. Come see why Colorado drives Phil Long!

Used Cars for Sale in Colorado Springs

Show Only


1249 Vehicles matching:
  • All Listings
  • Page 1 of 250


Phil Long Dealerships

1212A Motor City Dr
Directions Colorado Springs, CO 80905

  • Sales: (719) 387-5744
  • Service: (719) 387-7037
  • Finance: (719) 387-7162

Make an Inquiry